Why Eating Less Won’t Necessarily Make You Lose Weight

And What’s Really Controlling Your Metabolism

Author

My Longevity Experiment
February 17, 2025

New Study Challenges the Link Between Caloric Restriction and Reduced Exercise Performance

A groundbreaking study from the University of California, Riverside (UCR) challenges the long-held belief that reducing calorie intake inevitably leads to a decline in physical activity. Contrary to conventional wisdom, new research suggests that even with significant dietary restrictions, mammalian bodies can maintain prior activity levels.

Caloric Restriction and Exercise

Researchers conducted a controlled experiment using a treadmill while gradually decreasing their caloric intake. The highly controlled laboratory setting allowed for precise measurements, eliminating the inconsistencies found in real-world dieting and exercise habits.

Following three weeks of baseline data collection, scientists reduced the calorie intake of the mice by 20 percent for one week, followed by a more drastic 40 percent reduction the following week. The study included both normal mice and a group of ‘high-runner’ mice specifically bred for their strong running tendencies.

Minimal Impact on Running Performance

Surprisingly, researchers found that running performance remained largely unaffected by calorie reduction.

"Voluntary exercise [in mice] was remarkably resistant to reducing the amount of food by 20 percent and even by 40 percent," said biologist Theodore Garland Jr. from UCR. "They just kept running."

The only notable decrease in activity was observed in the high-runner mice subjected to the strictest diet, with an 11 percent drop in running distance. However, considering that these mice naturally run three times more than standard mice, this reduction was not deemed significant.

In all other scenarios, running routines remained consistent, contradicting previous assumptions that caloric restriction would lead to a decrease in voluntary exercise.

Stable Body Mass Despite Dieting

Another unexpected finding was the mice’s ability to maintain body mass despite a 20 percent reduction in calorie intake. Only a slight decrease in body mass was observed at the 40 percent reduction level. This result is unusual compared to similar past studies, prompting researchers to hypothesize the presence of a compensatory mechanism that prevents significant weight loss.

"There has to be some type of compensation going on if your food goes down by 40 percent and your weight doesn’t go down very much," Garland explained.

"Maybe that’s reducing other types of activities, or becoming metabolically more efficient, which we didn’t yet measure."

Implications for Dieting and Exercise

This study underscores the importance of maintaining exercise routines even when following a calorie-restricted diet. While the research was conducted on mice, it suggests that the body may have a greater ability to sustain physical activity levels under caloric deficits than previously believed.

These findings add to the growing body of evidence that effective weight loss requires a combination of dietary control and exercise. In a world facing rising obesity rates and associated health challenges, understanding the mechanics of weight management is crucial.

"We don’t want people on diets to say, I don’t have enough energy, so I’ll make up for it by not exercising," Garland stated.

"That would be counterproductive, and now we know, it doesn’t have to be this way."

This research offers valuable insights into the interplay between diet and exercise, reinforcing the message that physical activity remains essential even under calorie restrictions.

Study Links: