How Your Food Choices Fuel Anxiety & Depression

The Common Ingredient That is Wrecking Your Mood and Brain Chemistry

Author

My Longevity Experiment
April 23, 2025

How Blood Sugar Affects Mood and Mental Health

The relationship between food and emotional well-being is illustrated in everyday experiences. The brief "sugar high" that often follows the consumption of a sweet treat is a common example of food's immediate mood-boosting effect.

Conversely, the irritability and anger associated with being "hangry" reflect how the absence of food can fuel negative emotions. Both experiences highlight how fluctuations in blood sugar levels can significantly impact mood.

Blood Sugar Fluctuations and Mental Health

Recent scientific findings suggest that variations in blood sugar play a significant role in shaping emotional health through their influence on hormonal responses and the nervous system. These fluctuations are now being linked to increased risk of anxiety and depression.

Mental health is a complex topic influenced by numerous social, psychological and biological factors. Despite this complexity, a growing body of evidence from randomized controlled trials shows that diet is a key biological factor that affects the risk of developing symptoms of depression and anxiety, especially in women.

A family medicine resident with a Ph.D. in nutrition stated, “I have witnessed the fact that antidepressant medications work for some patients but not others. Thus, in my view, mental health treatment strategies should target every risk factor, including nutrition.”

The Role of the Glycemic Index

Much of the research connecting diet and mental health has focused on the Mediterranean diet or similar dietary patterns. This way of eating emphasizes vegetables, especially dark leafy greens, fruits, whole grains, legumes, nuts, olive oil and small portions of fish, meat and dairy. One notable feature of this diet is its low glycemic index.

The glycemic index measures how quickly foods raise blood sugar levels. High glycemic index foods, such as white rice, white bread, crackers and baked goods, can cause rapid spikes in blood sugar, which have been linked to a higher risk of depression and, to a lesser extent, anxiety.

In contrast, low glycemic index foods, including parboiled rice and al dente pasta, are absorbed more slowly and produce smaller spikes in blood sugar. These foods are associated with a reduced risk of mood disorders.

Hormonal Mechanisms Behind Mood Shifts

The physiological explanation for how food affects mood begins with the hormonal cascade triggered by sugar and carbohydrate consumption. Dopamine, a neurotransmitter linked to pleasure, is released after consuming high-carb foods, creating the temporary "sugar high."

Insulin is another hormone that comes into play, responsible for transporting sugar from the blood into cells. However, excessive intake of sugar or high glycemic index foods results in a dramatic insulin response, often followed by a sharp dip in blood sugar.

This drop triggers the release of adrenaline and noradrenaline, stress-related hormones that not only restore blood sugar but also induce emotional changes such as anxiety or aggression. These effects can surface four to five hours after carbohydrate consumption, leading to a delayed but notable emotional downturn.

Individual Variability and Gender Differences

The response to carbohydrate intake varies widely among individuals. Factors such as sex, genetic makeup, level of physical activity and gut microbiome diversity all influence blood sugar regulation. Notably, research has shown that women may be more sensitive to the glycemic index and the mental health impacts of diet.

Artificial sweeteners are not a suitable alternative. Data indicate that these, along with artificially sweetened beverages, are among the processed foods most strongly associated with depression.

Nutritional Strategies to Support Mental Health

While reducing sugar and high-carb food intake is a straightforward solution, more nuanced dietary strategies can also stabilize blood sugar and enhance mood:

  • Favor low glycemic index carbs like whole grain bread, parboiled rice and al dente pasta.

  • Consume carbohydrates earlier in the day, as hormonal rhythms make the body more efficient at managing blood sugar at those times.

  • Avoid eating carbohydrates alone. Combine them with proteins or healthy fats to slow digestion and reduce blood sugar spikes.

  • Eat carbohydrates at the end of a meal, after consuming vegetables and proteins first.

  • Begin meals with a salad dressed in olive oil and vinegar. The fiber, fat and acidity work together to slow sugar absorption.

Your Call to Action for How Blood Sugar Affects Mood and Mental Health

To support better mental health through nutrition, individuals should take proactive steps to stabilize their blood sugar. Replace high glycemic index foods with slower-digesting alternatives. Eat balanced meals that include protein and healthy fats. Adjust meal timing and food order to align with your body’s hormonal rhythms. While diet alone is not a cure for mental illness, it is a powerful tool that can significantly improve emotional stability, especially for women. Start today by making small, sustainable changes to your eating habits and track how they affect your mood over time.

Study Links: